Most Expensive A Game of Truth and Deceit Cards
The most expensive A Game of Truth and Deceit card is Pure Vanilla Cookie (088) (EXR) (Foil) at $349.99 on TCGplayer. These 25 chase cards are the most valuable in the set, updated on 17 Oct 2026.
Pure Vanilla Cookie (088) (EXR)
BS9-088 · EXR · Foil
$349.99
down 0.4%Dark Cacao Cookie (104) (EXR)
BS8-104 · EXR · Foil
$117.63
0.0%Shadow Milk Cookie (079) (SUR)
BS9-079 · SUR · Foil
$94.99
0.0%Golden Cheese Cookie (SSR)
BS9-024 · SSR · Foil
$79.20
0.0%Shadow Milk Cookie (055) (SUR)
BS9-055 · SUR · Foil
$77.75
0.0%Golden Cheese Cookie (027) (EXR)
BS8-027 · EXR · Foil
$73.75
down 12.3%Truthless Recluse (SUR)
BS9-035 · SUR · Foil
$61.00
down 5.1%Shadow Milk Cookie (030) (SUR)
BS9-030 · SUR · Foil
$58.39
down 2.9%Shadow Milk Cookie (102) (SUR)
BS9-102 · SUR · Foil
$47.41
0.0%Golden Cheese Cookie (027) (SUR)
BS8-027 · SUR · Foil
$41.91
0.0%Shadow Milk Cookie (010) (SUR)
BS9-010 · SUR · Foil
$39.99
0.0%Pure Vanilla Cookie (088) (SUR)
BS9-088 · SUR · Foil
$39.89
The 25 most expensive A Game of Truth and Deceit cards
| # | Card | Printing | Price | 30 d | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  | Pure Vanilla Cookie (088) (EXR) BS9-088 · EXR | Foil | $349.99 | – |
| 2 |  | Dark Cacao Cookie (104) (EXR) BS8-104 · EXR | Foil | $117.63 | down 0.4% |
| 3 |  | Shadow Milk Cookie (079) (SUR) BS9-079 · SUR | Foil | $94.99 | 0.0% |
| 4 |  | Golden Cheese Cookie (SSR) BS9-024 · SSR | Foil | $79.20 | 0.0% |
| 5 |  | Shadow Milk Cookie (055) (SUR) BS9-055 · SUR | Foil | $77.75 | 0.0% |
| 6 |  | Golden Cheese Cookie (027) (EXR) BS8-027 · EXR | Foil | $73.75 | 0.0% |
| 7 |  | Truthless Recluse (SUR) BS9-035 · SUR | Foil | $61.00 | down 12.3% |
| 8 |  | Shadow Milk Cookie (030) (SUR) BS9-030 · SUR | Foil | $58.39 | down 5.1% |
| 9 |  | Shadow Milk Cookie (102) (SUR) BS9-102 · SUR | Foil | $47.41 | down 2.9% |
| 10 |  | Golden Cheese Cookie (027) (SUR) BS8-027 · SUR | Foil | $41.91 | 0.0% |
| 11 |  | Shadow Milk Cookie (010) (SUR) BS9-010 · SUR | Foil | $39.99TruePrice | 0.0% |
| 12 |  | Pure Vanilla Cookie (088) (SUR) BS9-088 · SUR | Foil | $39.89 | 0.0% |
| 13 |  | Hollyberry Cookie (SSR) BS9-017 · SSR | Foil | $27.43 | down 2.8% |
| 14 |  | Dark Cacao Cookie (104) (SUR) BS8-104 · SUR | Foil | $26.51 | 0.0% |
| 15 |  | Burnt Cheese Cookie (SSR) BS8-032 · SSR | Foil | $26.44 | 0.0% |
| 16 |  | Black Sapphire Cookie (SSR) BS9-100 · SSR | Foil | $24.84 | down 0.9% |
| 17 |  | Caramel Arrow Cookie (SSR) BS8-120 · SSR | Foil | $23.99 | 0.0% |
| 18 |  | White Lily Cookie (SSR) BS9-078 · SSR | Foil | $23.49 | down 2.1% |
| 19 |  | Burning Spice Cookie (SUR) BS8-009 · SUR | Foil | $20.87 | 0.0% |
| 20 |  | Will of Nature (SUR) BS8-090 · SUR | Foil | $20.38 | down 0.2% |
| 21 |  | Peach Blossom Cookie (SSR) BS8-060 · SSR | Foil | $20.08 | 0.0% |
| 22 |  | Peak of Apathy (SUR) BS8-069 · SUR | Foil | $19.74 | down 1.2% |
| 23 |  | Shadow Milk Cookie (079) BS9-079 · UR | Foil | $19.39 | up 5.0% |
| 24 |  | Crunchy Chip Cookie (SSR) BS8-119 · SSR | Foil | $17.75TruePrice | 0.0% |
| 25 |  | Red Velvet Cookie (SSR) BS8-010 · SSR | Foil | $17.11 | down 19.6% |