Magic: The GatheringNightmare Price & Price History
$1.28
down 1.5% 7 dup 0.8% 30 dup 1.6% 1 y
- Rarity
- Rare
- Released
- 24 Mar 1997
- Prices since
- 8 Feb 2024
Fifth EditionNightmare Price History
Nightmare's lowest price is $0.47 and highest is $2.03 since Feb 2024
A Rare card from Fifth Edition, released Mar 1997. Market price $1.28, down 1.5% in 7 days.
- 7 ddown 1.5%
- 30 dup 0.8%
- 90 ddown 2.3%
- 1 yup 1.6%
- Below its highest36.9%
| Printing | Lowest listing | Mid | Market |
|---|---|---|---|
| Normal | $0.29 | $0.79 | $1.28 |
Also printed in
More from Fifth Edition
Get the latest price moves for your games
The cards going up and down, in your inbox. Free.
Unsubscribe in one click.
Questions about Nightmare
How much is Nightmare worth?
Nightmare is worth $1.28, its TCGplayer market price on 9 Oct 2026. The lowest listing is $0.29.
Is Nightmare going up?
It is holding steady: up 0.8% in 30 days, from $1.27 to $1.28. Over 1 year it is up 1.6%. It is 36.9% below its highest price of $2.03 (7 Jul 2025).
When was Nightmare released?
Nightmare came out in Fifth Edition, released on 24 Mar 1997.