Most Expensive Starter 1999 Cards

The most expensive Starter 1999 card is Grim Tutor at $92.99 on TCGplayer. These 25 chase cards are the most valuable in the set, updated on 9 Oct 2026.

Top 12

Full Starter 1999 card list

$92.99

$57.44

$17.57

$17.41

$15.79

$13.61

$10.94

$7.57

$7.31

$6.96

$6.78

$6.73

The 25 most expensive Starter 1999 cards

#	Card	Printing	Price	30 d
1	Grim Tutor 79 · R	Normal	$92.99	down 7.5%
2	Piracy 45 · R	Normal	$57.44	down 1.6%
3	Devastation 94 · R	Normal	$17.57	0.0%
4	Armageddon 6 · R	Normal	$17.41	up 2.9%
5	Time Warp 56 · R	Normal	$15.79	down 43.3%
6	Thunder Dragon 119 · R	Normal	$13.61	up 1.3%
7	Righteous Fury 23 · R	Normal	$10.94	up 2.0%
8	Goblin Settler 106 · U	Normal	$7.57	up 1.6%
9	Nature's Cloak 135 · R	Normal	$7.31	up 1.4%
10	Dakmor Sorceress 74 · R	Normal	$6.96	0.0%
11	Goblin General 101 · U	Normal	$6.78	up 0.1%
12	Summer Bloom 144 · R	Normal	$6.73	up 14.5%
13	Last Chance 110 · R	Normal	$5.72	up 4.2%
14	Goblin Lore 104 · U	Normal	$5.54	0.0%
15	Relentless Assault 115 · R	Normal	$5.52	0.0%
16	Wood Elves 153 · U	Normal	$5.42	up 28.4%
17	Angel of Light 1 · U	Normal	$4.86	0.0%
18	Alluring Scent 124 · R	Normal	$3.84	0.0%
19	Champion Lancer 11 · R	Normal	$3.82	up 4.7%
20	Silverback Ape 141 · U	Normal	$3.75	0.0%
21	Nature's Lore 136 · C	Normal	$3.24	up 1.9%
22	Counterspell 34 · U	Normal	$2.83	up 2.2%
23	Man-o'-War 41 · U	Normal	$2.32	up 13.7%
24	Dakmor Ghoul 70 · U	Normal	$2.19	up 3.3%
25	Wicked Pact 92 · R	Normal	$2.06	0.0%